Home Breaking Wrongly Convicted Individuals Exempted from Compensation Deductions in UK Justice System Overhaul
Wrongly Convicted Individuals Exempted from Compensation Deductions in UK Justice System Overhaul
Wrongly Convicted Individuals Exempted from Compensation Deductions in UK Justice System Overhaul

In a significant step towards rectifying miscarriages of justice, the UK government has announced that wrongly convicted individuals will no longer have living costs docked from their compensation payments. Justice Secretary Alex Chalk KC implemented the reform with immediate effect on Sunday, following public outrage surrounding the case of Andrew Malkinson.

Andrew Malkinson, who spent 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, welcomed the abolishment of the “unjust rule.” Last week, appeal judges quashed his conviction after DNA evidence linked another man to the crime. However, Mr. Malkinson had expressed concerns that expenses could be deducted from any compensation payment he might receive to cover the costs of his wrongful incarceration.

Responding to widespread demands to address the issue, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak supported the removal of these deductions, with Downing Street signalling that they were deemed unfair. Justice Secretary Alex Chalk has now updated the guidance, dating back to 2006, to eliminate living cost deductions from future payments under the miscarriage of justice compensation scheme.

While the reform has been widely welcomed, Andrew Malkinson urged for broader changes in the justice system to protect the innocent. He raised concerns about the police’s handling of evidence and the jury’s ability to convict with a 10-2 majority. Malkinson also expressed dissatisfaction with the miscarriage of justice watchdog, emphasising the need for greater accountability and efficiency in processing compensation claims.

However, advocates for the wrongly convicted are calling for further action, urging the government to repay the money already deducted from compensation received by previous miscarriage of justice victims. Justice Secretary Alex Chalk emphasised that fairness is a fundamental principle of the justice system, and victims of miscarriages of justice should not face deductions for saved living expenses.

Sir Bob Neill, the Conservative MP and chair of the Commons Justice Committee, praised the prompt action taken by Alex Chalk, acknowledging the tireless efforts of Andrew Malkinson, his family, and supporters in bringing attention to the issue. He suggested that the government should consider making ex-gratia payments on a case-by-case basis to redress the deductions already made.

Liberal Democrat justice spokesman Alistair Carmichael also voiced support for reviewing past cases where deductions were made and fully compensating the individuals wrongfully convicted. He criticised the practice of charging those who have suffered wrongful imprisonment for saved living expenses, terming it a “sick joke.”

The miscarriage of justice compensation scheme allows eligible individuals to apply for compensation within two years of being pardoned or having their convictions overturned. To qualify, they must demonstrate beyond reasonable doubt that they did not commit the offence and were not responsible for the non-disclosure of evidence. The maximum payment available under the scheme is £1 million for individuals imprisoned for over ten years.

Recommended for you

Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-11.33.14-1-1
MANHUNT Who is this man? Police hunt witness after brutal Northampton attack
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-11.22.04-1-1
UNDERCOVER STING Shocking First Photo of UK Paedophile Who Planned to Rape 9-Year-Old Girl
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-11.23.28-1-1
FREAK SLAMMED WITH JAIL Stalker Dad Jailed for Threats to Kill Ex and Her New Partner
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-11.09.26-1-1
SPOTTED HIM Urgent Hunt for Exeter Man in Assault Probe

Must READ

gunpoint-carjacker-busted-16-years-behind-bars
Gunpoint Carjacker Busted: 16 Years Behind Bars
second-man-nabbed-over-flood-of-hoax-police-calls
Second Man Nabbed Over Flood of Hoax Police Calls
gosport-heros-miraculous-recovery-after-heart-attack-at-wheel
Gosport Hero’s Miraculous Recovery After Heart Attack at Wheel
tragic-blaze-claims-life-in-whetstone-house-fire
Tragic Blaze Claims Life in Whetstone House Fire
investigation-launched-after-smoke-pours-from-fire-at-laundry-in-west-london-2
Massive Blaze Erupts at Industrial Laundry Unit in Park Royal
Met Cracks Down on London’s Biggest Phone Theft Ring, Seizes Thousands of Stolen Mobiles
Murder Probe Launched After Man, 30, Fatally Stabbed in Leicester Home
Man Arrested Over Suspicious Mosque Fire in Peacehaven
Van Driver Busted After Circling Maidstone Car Park Hunting for Child to Abuse
Murder Probe Launched After Man, 30, Fatally Stabbed in Leicester Home
Met Police hunt two men after brutal Holloway car park attack with firearm
Three Adventurous Cavers Rescued After 36-Hour Yorkshire Dales Drama
Dashcam Appeal After M20 Smash Near Folkestone

More For You

Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-07.18.41-1-1
STORM HITS Storm Amy Smashes Britain with 100mph Winds and Torrential Rain
kent-police-is-appealing-for-witnesses-following-a-reported-break-in-at-a-business-in-whitstable-fweTKl-3-1
HIT AND RUN Urgent Appeal After Hit-and-Run Leaves Pedestrian Critically Injured in Faversham
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-10.58.04-1-1
BRING HIM HOME Missing Man Klaidas Last Seen Near Blackfriars Bridge
John_Malkovich_1200_LT-1-1
HUNGER GAMES John Malkovich Takes on Villainous President Snow in Dystopian Thriller

More From UK News in Pictures

Three Adventurous Cavers Rescued After 36-Hour Yorkshire Dales Drama
Asylum Seeker Skates Jail After Creepy Online Chat with ‘14-Year-Old’
Murder Probe Launched After Man, 30, Fatally Stabbed in Leicester Home
Dame Jilly Cooper, legendary romance author behind hits like Rivals and The Man Who Made Husbands Jealous, has died aged 88
Three Adventurous Cavers Rescued After 36-Hour Yorkshire Dales Drama
Woman Jailed for Running Down Man Near Sittingbourne
Murder Probe Launched After Man, 30, Fatally Stabbed in Leicester Home
Imam Wounded in Hounslow as Police Probe Possible Motive
Major Road Closed following Collision in Southampton
Worcester on Edge as Missing Woman Sparks Urgent Police Search
eltham-man-caught-with-child-sexual-abuse-images-featured-1-1
Paedophile Armed With Shocking Child Abuse Images Held Off for Years Before Court Action
542219949_1202701335228063_7076088472067200755_n-1
JUSTICE SERVED Meet the criminals locked up across south London this September 2025 – from a twisted teacher to a deadly biker, their shocking crimes laid bare
police-met-stock-4-742x536-4-copy-1
KILLED BY POLICE VAN Man Dies After Crash Near Westminster Bridge
FB_IMG_1759585732298-1-1
MIDNIGHT ATTACK Man Wanted Over Brutal Assault in Lewes
51180338-8fb0-4808-b060-764312b0feb2-1-1
“Bingo Brawling”: Understanding the Competitive Side of Bingo
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-18.31.37-1-1
TRAFFIC CHAOS Car Flips Over at Busy Folkestone Junction, Causing Chaos
SEARCH CONTINUES New CCTV Clip Emerges in Hunt for Missing Maidstone Woman
Screenshot-2025-10-04-130518-1-1
BRIGHTON SHOCK Teen Found Bleeding in City Centre Late at Night
police-met-stock-5-copy-2-1
FATAL CRASH IOPC Launches Urgent Witness Appeal After Fatal Collision Involving Met Police
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-11.48.08-1-1
LOCKED UP Leeds Man Banged Up for Harehills Chaos
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-11.42.15-1-1
Sex Offender Jailed for Making Indecent Child Images

More From UKNIP

Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-09.33.00-1-1
Hidden Gems for Nighttime Entertainment Across Kent
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-08.35.31-1-1
TRAGIC CRASH British Teen Who Served Dubai Jail Sentence for Sex with 17-Year-Old Killed in Police Chase Crash
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-08.06.17-1-1
HORRIFIC ATTACK Man Suffered Broken Knuckle in Chesham Station Assault
Screenshot-2025-10-04-at-07.32.08-1-1
SPOONS KNIFE ATTACK Stabbing Shocker in Leatherhead Town Centre