New sentencing guidelines have come under fire after it was revealed that offenders from ethnic, cultural, or faith minority backgrounds may receive more lenient treatment when facing jail time.
The guidance, which suggests courts should consider pre-sentence reports for certain offenders before deciding on imprisonment, lists ethnic and cultural minorities among the groups eligible for special consideration.
Critics Condemn ‘Two-Tier’ Justice System
The policy has been met with outrage, with critics branding it “brazen two-tier justice.”
The guidelines, issued under the Labour government, state that pre-sentence reports should be considered if the offender belongs to one or more of the following groups:
- Those facing their first custodial sentence or one of two years or less
- Young adults aged 18-25
- Women
- People from ethnic, cultural, or faith minority communities
- Those who are pregnant or post-natal
- Primary carers for dependent relatives
The document also mentions additional considerations, such as whether the offender has addiction issues, a disability, or mental health concerns.
Legal Experts Question Fairness
Critics argue that this approach undermines equal justice, suggesting that ethnicity or cultural background should have no impact on sentencing.
A senior legal expert commented:
“Sentencing should be based on the severity of the crime, not on the offender’s identity. The idea that someone could receive a more lenient sentence because of their background is deeply concerning.”
Government Defends Guidance
Supporters of the guidance argue that it aims to address systemic disparities in the criminal justice system, ensuring that certain groups, who may face disadvantages, are not unfairly impacted by sentencing.
A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said:
“The guidance ensures that sentencing considers personal circumstances where relevant, but ultimately, all offenders are judged on the severity of their crimes.”
Public Backlash Grows
Despite the government’s defense, many have expressed outrage on social media, calling for an end to what they see as preferential treatment.
One user wrote:
“Justice should be blind. This is blatant discrimination against everyone else.”
Another added:
“If you commit a crime, you should face the same punishment—no matter your background.”
What Happens Next?
With public and political pressure mounting, calls are growing for a review of the policy to ensure sentencing remains equal and fair for all offenders. Whether the government will amend or withdraw the guidance remains to be seen.
This remains a developing story, with further updates expected as officials respond to the backlash.
