The headmaster of All Saints Catholic High School, Sean Pender, is facing serious allegations over his handling of a knife-related incident involving the teenager accused of murdering 15-year-old Harvey Willgoose.

Reports claim that the suspect had previously been caught bringing a knife into the school and was suspended as a result. However, parents were allegedly misled about the incident, with Pender denying the seriousness of the situation in a letter sent to families.

Allegations of a Cover-Up

It is claimed that following the suspect’s initial suspension, the school informed parents that the police presence on-site was merely for an “educational” visit—downplaying concerns that a dangerous weapon had been found on school grounds.

Despite the alleged previous knife incident, the suspect was reportedly allowed back into the school, where he is accused of fatally stabbing Harvey Willgoose.

The tragedy has sparked public outrage, with parents demanding answers and accountability from school leadership over why the suspect was permitted to return.