In a twist of events, a revelation by ITV News has cast doubt on Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s claims that no decision had been made regarding the Manchester leg of the HS2 high-speed rail project. The revelation comes after Sunak posted a video on X outlining the scrapping of the rest of HS2, recorded at Downing Street at least three days ago, before his appearance at the Conservative Party Conference in Manchester.
The video, set against the backdrop of a Union flag and a hanging picture, was verified by ITV News analysis, confirming that it was recorded in a room at No 10 Downing Street, historically used for welcoming world leaders.
Throughout the week, Sunak insisted that a decision on HS2 had not been finalised. However, the timing of the recorded video has now raised questions about the Chancellor’s earlier statements. On October 1, Sunak told the BBC’s Laura Kuennsberg that spades were already in the ground for HS2, downplaying speculation. Yet, the video’s emergence contradicts this claim.
When pressed by ITV News Political Editor Robert Peston, Sunak hinted at changes to the project, indicating a willingness to make bold decisions. However, the video’s pre-recording suggests a lack of transparency in the process.
Responding to the controversy, Sunak’s spokesperson stated that the decision was taken by the cabinet, with legal responsibility resting on the transport secretary. Transport Secretary Mark Harper confirmed that the decision was made on Tuesday and approved by the cabinet on Wednesday.
The decision to abandon the northern leg of HS2 has sparked criticism, with former Prime Minister David Cameron among those expressing disapproval. Harper defended the decision, citing changing facts, escalating costs, and post-pandemic travel patterns.
Rishi Sunak faces additional scrutiny as he is reported to Police Scotland over comments made about Nicola Sturgeon during his Tory Party conference speech. The general secretary of the Alba Party filed a complaint, questioning whether Sunak committed contempt of court by mentioning Sturgeon, who is under a live police investigation.
Amid the HS2 controversy and the Sturgeon incident, calls for stronger rules around truthfulness in politics have resurfaced. Green MP Caroline Lucas urged Prime Minister Rishi Sunak to familiarise himself with the Nolan Principles of public life, emphasising the need for honesty among holders of public office. The debate on the integrity of political statements continues to dominate discussions following a tumultuous Conservative Party Conference.
