The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has announced that no criminal charges will be brought against a South Wales Police officer linked to the tragic deaths of Harvey Evans, 15, and Kyrees Sullivan, 16. The decision comes after an exhaustive investigation into the incident, which took place in Ely, Cardiff.
Tragic Incident in Ely
The fatal crash occurred when Harvey and Kyrees, riding an electric bicycle, collided in the residential area of Ely. The incident, which happened last year, shocked the community and prompted questions about the role of police who were reportedly in the vicinity at the time. Initial reports suggested that a police pursuit may have preceded the crash, although official details remain sparse.
CPS Findings: Insufficient Evidence
The Crown Prosecution Service reviewed the evidence related to allegations of dangerous driving by the officer involved. After thorough examination, the CPS concluded that there was “insufficient evidence to provide a realistic prospect of conviction.”
Malcolm McHaffie, Head of the CPS Special Crime Division, expressed sympathy for the families, stating:
“Our thoughts remain with the families and friends of the two teenagers following their tragic deaths. We fully understand that this will be disappointing news for the families of both boys.”
He explained that the decision was based strictly on the evidence available, not on the gravity of the loss. The Full Code Test, which requires both sufficient evidence and public interest for prosecution, was applied to the case.
Independent Investigation
The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) carried out an investigation into the circumstances of the crash, gathering evidence to determine whether the officer’s actions amounted to dangerous driving. This evidence was submitted to the CPS, which ultimately decided not to pursue charges.
Public Reaction: Mixed Responses
The decision has stirred mixed reactions both locally and online. Some community members feel that justice has not been served, while others acknowledge the challenges of proving criminal culpability in such incidents.
One social media user posted:
“How can there be no accountability when two kids are dead?”
Another countered:
“Evidence matters—feelings don’t dictate justice. The CPS made a decision based on facts.”
The case has sparked discussions on police accountability, road safety, and the legal process, leaving the families of the victims still searching for answers.
Victims’ Right to Review
The CPS has informed the families about their right to request a review of the decision under the Victim’s Right to Review Scheme. This process allows families to challenge the decision if they believe the evidence was not properly considered.
McHaffie also offered to meet with the families to explain the decision in detail, acknowledging the ongoing pain and frustration they may feel.
Moving Forward: Calls for Safety Measures
The tragic deaths of Harvey and Kyrees have led to calls for improved safety measures for electric bicycles and better community-police relations in Ely. Local leaders are urging authorities to focus on educating young people about road safety while also ensuring accountability in policing practices.
Councillor Bethan Davies, representing Ely, said:
“We must honour the memory of these young lives by working together to ensure safer streets and greater trust between residents and police.”
Support for Families
Community groups are continuing to support the victims’ families, offering counselling and assistance as they process the outcome. Campaigners are also planning a vigil to remember the boys and call for more stringent regulations regarding electric bike use among teenagers.
While the CPS decision has brought legal closure, the emotional impact of the incident continues to resonate throughout Cardiff, highlighting the complexities of balancing justice and accountability.
